While you need to consider the impact of tax when planning your retirement savings strategy, it shouldn’t be your primary concern. That said, it needs to be factored in both while saving for retirement, and during retirement, given the different tax treatment of those two scenarios.
Broadly speaking, the taxation process can be summed up as “exempt-exempt-tax”, consistent with regulations in many countries globally. You are exempt from tax on contributions made while saving for retirement (up to certain limits), and you are exempt from gains on the investments while you are saving, but you are subject to income tax upon retirement as you draw down your savings.
Retirement savings vehicles
The key retirement-savings vehicles are retirement annuities and pension or provident funds. The main difference between these products is that the latter are employer-provided and are typically mandated in most large businesses. Retirement annuities are typically used by self-employed individuals, employees in organisations that don’t offer a pension or provident fund, and those who want to increase their retirement savings.
The main benefits of retirement annuities are that you are able to contribute to as many of them as you wish, you can stop contributing whenever you want, and they are transferable. There is additional flexibility in that lump-sum retirement annuities are available. This is a tax-efficient way to house any excess savings, as you are able to use the lump-sum amount to reduce your income tax liability in that year.
The Taxation Laws Amendment Act
The signing into law of the Taxation Laws Amendment Act (2015) and Tax Administration Laws Amendment Act (2015) by former President Jacob Zuma prompted many questions from those who are saving for retirement through retirement annuities, pensions and provident funds.
In short, the act ensures that the tax benefits of contributions to provident funds, pension funds and retirement annuities are now on an equal footing.
It is also important to note that most people currently saving for retirement will be unaffected or better off under the changes. High-income earners are likely to be the most affected by the changes.
How the Act affects you: Before retirement
The tax deduction increases from 15% to 27.5% of taxable income or remuneration, up to a maximum of R350 000 annually, on contributions made towards structured retirement savings. It now applies across the board, in other words, to provident funds, pension funds and retirement annuities.
The distinction between retirement funding and non-retirement funding income has also been removed. That means all clients who were members of a pension or provident fund, and therefore unable to take out a retirement annuity, can now top-up to the limit of 27.5%.
Also, only employees are able to claim contributions, regardless of whether they actually made them (companies will often contribute to a pension).
How the Act affects you: After retirement
The laws mean that the rules that governed provident funds changed to the same as those that governed pension funds. Provident fund members can only withdraw one-third of those savings at retirement, and they are required to purchase an annuity with the remaining two-thirds.
Effectively, one could argue that the government is looking to help protect retirees by enforcing compulsory preservation and making it impossible for hard-earned savings to be withdrawn in a lump sum.
Any lump sum withdrawn at retirement above a minimum threshold (currently R25 000) is taxable. Between R25 000 and R660 000, the tax rate is 18%, between R660 000 and R990 000 it is 27%, and over R990 000, it is 36%.
How is your annuity taxed?
The remaining two-thirds of your savings received in the form of an annuity (pension) is taxable. But this would only be for the amounts that exceed certain thresholds published by the South African Revenue Service. For the current tax year (to end-February 2019), these thresholds are:
- Under 65: R78 150 per year
- Between 65 and 74: R121 000 per year
- 75 and above: R135 300 per year
For example, if your pension (annuity) was R20 000 a month at age 65, your tax rate would fall into the second bracket of 26%. The tax that you would pay is R2 079.31 per month leaving you with a net income of R17 920.69 per month.
Are early withdrawals possible?
The act does not affect what happens if you leave a provident (or pension) fund before retirement, either because of changing jobs, retrenchment or dismissal.
Also, the withdrawal of the entire amount of a pension or provident fund is still possible before retirement, although this is very ill-advised. (For retirement annuities, withdrawals are only possible on early retirement due to ill-health or on emigration.)
Tax-free savings accounts
Lastly, tax-free savings accounts are another element those saving for retirement need to consider. The tax-free savings account structure offers an interesting way to supplement structured retirement savings. It would be difficult to argue that a tax-free savings account is an absolute alternative to products like retirement annuities and pension funds.
Tax-free savings accounts allow the investment of R33 000 a year (up to a lifetime limit of R500 000, likely to be revised upward in future). These investments can be made in a number of different asset classes and all gains on these investments (capital gains, dividends and interest) are completely tax-free.
However, contributions are not tax-deductible, which is why tax-free savings accounts should only be considered as a way to supplement whatever retirement savings an individual already has, especially if they are at (or near) the contribution limit of 27.5% of taxable income or remuneration.
With so many complex factors to consider and a very long time horizon, it is important to get professional investment advice for your retirement savings, as well as the tax impact of choices you will need to make.
Disclaimer: This article is meant only as information and should not be taken as financial advice. For tailored financial advice, please contact your financial adviser.